Content
* Relevance: Does the speech directly address the chosen topic and stay within the scope of the given prompt?
* Organization: Is the speech logically structured with a clear introduction, body, and conclusion? Is there a strong thesis statement?
* Information & Evidence: Is the speech well-researched and supported by relevant facts, statistics, examples, and expert opinions? Is the evidence credible and accurately presented?
* Analysis & Interpretation: Does the speaker go beyond simply stating facts and offer insightful analysis, interpretation, and original perspectives?
* Creativity & Originality: Does the speech demonstrate a fresh approach to the topic and avoid common clichés or overused arguments?
Delivery
* Clarity & Fluency: Is the speaker's voice clear, articulate, and free from distracting mannerisms or hesitations? Is the language appropriate for the audience and the occasion?
* Eye Contact & Engagement: Does the speaker maintain strong eye contact with the audience and engage them effectively? Is the speaker's body language confident and appropriate?
* Enthusiasm & Passion: Does the speaker show genuine enthusiasm and interest in the topic, which helps engage the audience?
* Vocal Variety & Dynamics: Does the speaker use vocal variety, including changes in pace, pitch, and volume, to emphasize key points and maintain audience interest?
* Confidence & Poise: Does the speaker project an air of confidence and composure, even under pressure?
Overall Impression
* Impact & Persuasiveness: Does the speech leave a lasting impression on the audience? Is the speaker persuasive in their arguments and effectively convey their message?
* Time Management: Does the speaker stay within the allotted time limit, ensuring the speech is neither too short nor too long?
* Preparation & Research: Does the speech demonstrate evidence of thorough preparation and research, including the ability to cite sources accurately?
* Adherence to Rules: Does the speaker follow the rules of the competition, such as time limits, topic restrictions, and format requirements?
Additional factors that may be considered:
* Adaptability: How well does the speaker adjust to unexpected questions or challenges during the speech?
* Humor & Wit: Does the speaker effectively incorporate humor or wit to engage the audience without detracting from the message?
* Presentation Aids: If allowed, are visual aids effectively used to enhance the presentation and support the arguments?
It's important to note that the specific criteria and their weighting may vary depending on the competition or the individual judges. It's also crucial to consider the context of the speech – the audience, the occasion, and the intended purpose – when assessing its effectiveness.